Thursday, August 25, 2011

Domestic Fail

When I was 8 or 9 years old, I was in a little cooking 4H club. My mom and aunt were the leaders, and there were girls in the club from the neighborhood. My sister and cousin were also in the club. It was a great experience—I still remember the importance to leveling dry ingredients with a straight edge, how to boil eggs to avoid the green ring on the yoke, and why it's good to combine all dry ingredients before adding them to the rest of the mixture.

The culmination of our little club was entering a baked good into the county fair. I made lemon bars from the old Lion House cookbook, and I received a blue ribbon. I still remember being very proud of those lemon bars. I could conquer the world if I could make those. I've had a lot of baking and cooking successes and failures over the years, but overall, I consider myself fairly adept at cooking.

Fast forward to today: I'm in a book club that's meeting tonight. We're discussing Stargirl (which I've loved since the first time I read it). One of the most vivid memories from that book is the description of Stargirl's yellow dress when she goes to the school dance. I thought lemon bars would be the perfect treat to take. (Because they're yellow. Get it?)

I set out this afternoon to make said lemon bars from the updated version of the Lion House cookbook. After they cooled a little bit, I tried them to see how they were. Let me tell you, they were a classic failure. They didn't cook long enough and the lemon flavor was too strong (it wasn't sweet enough). In looking back, I'm sure it's my fault for two reasons:

1. Lemon rind vs. lemon peel
The recipe called for "lemon rind." I'm no professional cook, but isn't the rind the peel? After a quick Google search, it seems some are of the opinion that the rind is the peel and others think it is the white part just under the peel. If it's the white part under the peel, I don't know how you get to it without using the yellow part of the peel. Well, I included some yellow and white part to cover my bases, but maybe it was too much. I was supposed to do the rind of one lemon. Maybe my lemon was too large, or maybe I shouldn't have included any of the white part. (Any help from cooks more professional than I would be greatly appreciated.)

2. I don't understand large time ranges
I was supposed to cook the lemon bars for "18 to 25 minutes." Is it strange to anyone else that there's a seven-minute range? What does that mean? You can't exactly do a toothpick test on lemon bars because they're too gooey. How do you know when they're done? I left them in for almost the entire 25 minutes, but after cooling, I tried to cut them, and they were totally soupy. Clearly, whatever time I cooked them for wasn't enough.

I'm not sure what all of this says about my cooking skills. It could be that my nine-year-old self was a much better cook than my current self. Or maybe my nine-year-old self was a good cook under the close supervision of my mother (who will always be the epitome of domesticity to me).

I could probably make some obvious reference to a saying about what to do when life gives you lemons, but I won't. Instead, I have just one thing to say about this experience: this website makes me feel so much better about my life.

3 comments:

Jill said...

1. I think maybe it would have been more clear for the cookbook writers to use the term "zest" instead of "rind". When I hear "rind" I think of the whole peel. The pith (white part) shouldn't be used in baking since it is usually bitter. Just the yellow outer part of the peel should be used.
2. As you mentioned the large time frame for baking is tricky. You'd think a good recipe would be more precise, although I've heard that with some great recipes "you can just kind of tell". ;) I think maybe judging by color might work best with lemon bars. If the lemon filling is a nice golden brown color I think that would be a good indicator of done-ness.
At any rate that's my input as a domestic guru. (HA!)
Also, I think you must have been sending me mental vibes about how much you wish I could be at your book club because I got a really strong hankering to read Stargirl a couple of days ago.
I'm sorry about the domestic fail but I think you are terrific even if your recent lemon bars weren't. And I am still laughing at the cookie monster cupcakes on that blog.

Ashley said...

I just want to thank you for giving me some laughing out loud entertainment for tonight--that craft fail site was maybe too much to handle only because we have all been there. I totally know how you feel, I undercooked a brownie mix earlier this week. Grandma once told me you don't become a great cook overnight. She is right but when will we all become as good of cooks as our moms?

graham and heather said...

I am betting you were just better at 9. :) No, I have done the same thing with stuff I have made before and then it fails. Graham usually asks if I used egg substitute, like that is the usually culprit and sadly it isn't always. Oh and thanks for the craft fails, those are awesome!